Pinetop, Arizona · Independent agency since 2005
We shop 20+ carriers.
You keep the savings.
Auto, home, cabin, boat, RV and more — one local agent compares coverage side by side, explains it in plain language, and stays with you for years.
Prefer to talk? Call 480-855-7000 — Mon–Fri, 8 AM – 4 PM (Arizona time).
Coverage
Protection for everything you've worked for
Auto Insurance
Liability, collision, glass and more — compared across 20+ carriers.
Explore coverage →Home Insurance
Insured to true rebuild cost, with wildfire, hail and liability protection.
Explore coverage →Boat & Watercraft Insurance
Boats, pontoons and jet skis — on the water and in storage.
Explore coverage →Classic Car Insurance
Agreed value coverage that protects what your classic is truly worth.
Explore coverage →Condo Insurance
Interior, upgrades and belongings, sized to your HOA master policy.
Explore coverage →Flood Insurance
Monsoon-ready protection for your structure and belongings.
Explore coverage →Motorcycle Insurance
Rider liability, custom parts, gear and roadside help.
Explore coverage →Renters Insurance
Your belongings and liability, usually for a few dollars a month.
Explore coverage →RV Insurance
Motorhomes and trailers — vehicle, contents and campsite liability.
Explore coverage →Umbrella Insurance
$1M+ of extra liability above your auto, home and rentals.
Explore coverage →How it works
Better coverage in three easy steps
- Tell us what you're protecting
A quick call or online request — your vehicles, home, toys, and what matters most to you.
- We shop the market
We compare limits, deductibles, and price across 20+ carriers and line them up side by side.
- You choose with confidence
We explain every option in plain language, then handle the paperwork and stay with you at every renewal.
The independent difference
How an independent agency compares
One agent, many carriers, and a real person in your corner for the life of your policy.
| Features & services | Canyon Lands | Captive agent | Online & 1-800 companies |
|---|---|---|---|
| Access to multiple companies and a wide range of products | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ |
| Easy switching from company to company without hassle | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ |
| Unbiased and objective advice | ✓ | Tries to sell & support only their one company | Tries to sell & support only their one company |
| Claims assistance and advocacy | ✓ | Adjusters are often exclusive to the one company | No help: you vs. the adjuster |
| Policy service from the same person you bought from | ✓ | ✕Sent to a call center | You'll likely never talk to the same person twice |
Why Canyon Lands
Local roots. A whole market of options.
Captive agents can offer one company's products. As an independent agency, we bring you the market — national names and regional specialists that write well in the White Mountains and across Arizona.
- Same-day quotes on most policies
- Plain-language coverage reviews
- Claims guidance when you need it most
- Renewal check-ins so your coverage keeps pace with your life
Our partner carriers
- Acuity
- American Modern
- American Summit
- Branch
- Bristol West
- Clearcover
- Commonwealth
- Covertree
- Foremost
- Foremost Signature
- GEICO
- Hagerty
- Liberty Mutual
- Markel
- Mercury Insurance
- National General
- Nationwide
- Openly
- PersonalUmbrella.com
- Progressive
- Selective
- Steadily Insurance
- Stillwater
- The General (formerly Dairyland)
- The Hartford
- Travelers
- US Assure
- West Bend
From the blog
Straight answers from a licensed agent
How Much Should Auto Insurance Cost?
Ryan Pfaff explains why the right auto insurance price depends on what you're protecting — and why value beats the lowest premium.
Read the article →Home InsuranceHow Much Home Insurance Should You Carry?
Rebuild cost vs. market value, extended replacement cost, and liability — Ryan Pfaff on how to size your home insurance.
Read the article →Umbrella InsuranceUmbrella Insurance Explained: Why an Umbrella Policy Is Important for Almost Everyone
What umbrella insurance covers, what you need to qualify, and why it's not just for the wealthy.
Read the article →Questions we hear every day
What is an independent insurance agency?
We work for you, not one insurance company. We compare quotes from more than 20 carriers and recommend the policy that gives you the best protection for your budget.
Which states do you insure?
We're licensed in Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Idaho, Illinois, Iowa, Kentucky, Minnesota, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Mexico, North Dakota, Oregon, Tennessee, Utah, Washington, Wisconsin and Wyoming.
Does it cost anything to get a quote?
Quotes are always free. Most clients have options in hand the same business day.
Can I keep working with you if I move?
Yes. Because we're licensed in 20 states, many clients keep their agent when they relocate.
How do I make a payment or file a claim?
Your carrier handles payments and claims directly, 24/7. Visit our Client Center for carrier links, or call us and we'll walk you through it.